Navigating Self-Defense: Politeness and Consideration vs. Matching Energy
- william demuth
- 1 day ago
- 4 min read
Updated: 1 hour ago
Self-defense is commonly thought of as a physical skillset—however, much of effective self-defense is rooted in psychology and interpersonal communication. When confronted with potential conflict, individuals often grapple with a key decision: Should they respond with politeness and consideration, seeking to de-escalate, or should they "match energy"—mirroring the aggressor’s tone or aggression—to assert boundaries or discourage further hostility? The answer is nuanced, depending on context, personal safety, and the ultimate goal of the interaction.
The Power of Politeness and Consideration
Approaching a confrontation with politeness and consideration can be a powerful first line of defense. Politeness can:
Defuse tense encounters: Respectful communication often disengages the other party’s aggression, making escalation less likely.
Position you as non-threatening: An attacker may reconsider if their target appears cooperative or unyielding to provocation.
Preserve evidence of good intent: Should the situation be scrutinized by authorities, your calm, considerate demeanor demonstrates efforts to avoid confrontation.
Example: When accosted verbally on the street, using calm words like, "I don’t want any trouble," or "Please let’s not do this," may give an aggressor pause or de-escalate their anger.
The Case for Matching Energy
Conversely, there are scenarios where matching the other person’s energy or tone can be beneficial, especially if:
The aggressor interprets kindness as weakness, emboldening them further.
The encounter has crossed a threshold of imminent danger where assertiveness is needed.
Clear, confident resistance is required to set boundaries and signal readiness to defend oneself if necessary.
Benefits of Matching Energy
Deterrence: Displaying confidence and readiness can discourage an aggressor from advancing, as they may perceive you as a challenging target.
Boundary Setting: A firm response communicates that you won’t tolerate threats, potentially stopping the situation from worsening.
Preparation for Physical Defense: Matching energy keeps you mentally and physically ready to respond if the situation turns violent.
Matching energy does not mean escalating violence, but it does imply meeting the intensity with assertive, clear communication or body language. For example, using a firm voice, strong posture, and unwavering eye contact to say, “Back away now!” may communicate resolve, causing hesitation in an aggressor.
Weighing the Approach: Context Matters
Neither strategy is automatically superior—choosing the right approach hinges on several factors:
Nature of the threat: Is the aggressor intoxicated, emotionally unstable, or making threats?
Environment: Are you in public or isolated? Can others assist if needed?
Personal capability: Are you physically able to defend yourself if escalation occurs?
Most self-defense experts advise starting with de-escalation: maintain politeness and calmly set boundaries. If the situation intensifies, increasing assertiveness and matching the other person’s energy may become necessary to protect yourself.
Real-World Example
Imagine you’re walking alone at night, and someone approaches, yelling aggressively about a perceived slight. A polite response might be, “I’m sorry if I upset you, I didn’t mean to. Let’s both stay calm.” If they continue to advance, ignoring your attempts to de-escalate, you might shift to matching energy: “Do you me a favor and talk to me from right there. I don’t want trouble, but I will protect myself.” This progression allows you to adapt to the situation’s intensity while prioritizing your safety.
Blending the Tactics
An effective self-defense mindset blends politeness and consideration with the flexibility to increase firmness as required. The priority is always personal safety—acting in ways that maximize your chances of avoiding harm, whether through respectful discourse or assertive boundary-setting. Listening to your intuition and being adaptable is vital: sometimes, politeness opens doors to resolution, and sometimes, readiness to match energy discourages escalation.
Balancing the Two Approaches
The key to effective self-defense lies in balancing politeness and matching energy based on the context. Here are some guidelines to help decide which approach to use:
Assess the Threat Level: Evaluate the aggressor’s behavior. Are they shouting, posturing, or physically advancing? Politeness works best for verbal conflicts, while matching energy may be necessary for physical threats.
Read the Environment: In public, politeness can leverage social pressure to your advantage. In isolated settings, matching energy may be more effective to deter an attack.
Know Your Capabilities: Be honest about your physical and mental ability to handle a confrontation. If you’re untrained in physical self-defense, politeness may be safer.
Trust Your Instincts: If a situation feels dangerous, don’t hesitate to shift from politeness to a more assertive stance or to disengage entirely if possible.
Bottom line: Both politeness and assertive “matching energy” have roles in self-defense. Understanding the dynamics at play—and being prepared to shift between strategies as needed—empowers you to navigate conflict with confidence and composure.
Online Violence Prevention and Defensive Tactics Training Brought To You By Generous Supporters
The Center for Violence Prevention and Self-Defense (CVPSD) is a nonprofit organization dedicated to reducing violence by educating at-risk individuals and communities.
Through a combination of online and in-person training, workshops, and seminars, CVPSD provides practical self-defense skills, violence prevention strategies, risk assessment tools, and guidance on setting personal and relationship boundaries.
Partnering with public and private organizations, schools, nonprofits, community groups, and government agencies—including those under the General Services Administration (GSA)—CVPSD works to empower individuals with the knowledge and skill