When it comes to home defense, people are often drawn to the idea of clearing their home of intruders, room by room, as they may have seen in movies or on TV. However, the reality of navigating confined spaces with unknown threats is far more dangerous than many realize. Statistics from military operations show just how risky it is to clear rooms in close-quarters combat (CQC).
For civilians, the best strategy for defending your home may not be to go on the offensive but rather to create a hardpoint—a defensible position within your home—where you can safely wait for help to arrive.
Here’s why a hardpoint approach is generally safer and more effective for protecting yourself and your family during a home invasion.
The Realities of Clearing Rooms: Military Data Points to High Risk
Even highly trained military personnel face significant risks when clearing buildings. In urban warfare scenarios, clearing rooms and houses is one of the most dangerous tasks, with casualty rates for military units performing CQC operations reaching 10-25% depending on the situation. These elevated risks stem from a combination of factors:
Constrained Movement and Limited Visibility: Narrow hallways and small rooms restrict movement and make it difficult to assess threats. Attackers are highly vulnerable when entering new rooms, with limited ability to dodge or evade.
Booby Traps and Ambush Points: In some military operations, up to 20-30% of casualties result from improvised explosive devices (IEDs) and traps. While this is less common in civilian situations, criminals can still set up ambush points, or simply use tight spaces to their advantage.
Defender’s Advantage: Military data show that attackers are at a disadvantage when they lack knowledge of a building’s layout and are forced to engage defenders in confined spaces. An intruder inside your home may already have the element of surprise, but moving through your own home in search of them gives them more chances to exploit that advantage.
This data points to a critical fact: even for highly trained professionals, actively searching for and clearing rooms of potential threats is fraught with risk. For a civilian without specialized training, moving room to room to engage an intruder amplifies these dangers.
The Hardpoint: A Safer, Defensive Strategy
Instead of attempting to clear your home of intruders, a safer approach is to establish a hardpoint—a defensible position within your home where you and your loved ones can retreat, lock down, and prepare to defend yourselves if necessary. This strategy gives you the advantage, putting you in control of the situation rather than exposing you to the risks of close-quarters combat. Here’s how to set up and utilize a hardpoint effectively:
Choose the Right Location: Ideally, the hardpoint should be in a room with a strong, lockable door, such as a bedroom. The room should also have access to a phone to call for help and, if possible, a window for an additional escape route or to communicate with responders.
Fortify the Door: Invest in a sturdy door with a quality lock and, if possible, add a security bar or door brace to make forced entry more difficult. The longer it takes for an intruder to get in, the more time you have to call for help and prepare to defend yourself.
Arm Yourself and Take a Defensive Position: If you own a legally acquired firearm or other self-defense tools, now is the time to retrieve it. Take a position of cover—such as behind a bed or heavy furniture—where you have a clear view of the door. This position allows you to maintain control over the entry point while minimizing your exposure to danger.
Call for Help: Once secure in your hardpoint, immediately call 911. Give your address and let the dispatcher know you have locked yourself in a safe room with your family. By staying on the line, you’ll provide law enforcement with valuable information and updates until they arrive.
Protecting Your Family: Avoiding Crossfire: A common defensive scenario involves positioning yourself between attackers and your family. While this may seem protective, it unfortunately puts your loved ones in the line of fire. As you develop your defensive plan, consider this risk and strategize accordingly.
A common defensive scenario involves positioning yourself between attackers and your family. While this may seem protective, it unfortunately puts your loved ones in the line of fire. As you develop your defensive plan, consider this risk and strategize accordingly.
Why Ambushing from a Hardpoint is Safer Than Room-Clearing
Creating a hardpoint and taking a defensive posture turns the tables, putting the advantage back in your hands. Here’s how:
Controlled Positioning: In a hardpoint, you are set up defensively in a known, fortified position. The intruder, by contrast, would have to enter a new room (your hardpoint) without knowing where you are positioned, giving you the advantage if forced to engage.
Defender’s Advantage: Just as military data shows attackers in room-clearing missions are highly vulnerable, an intruder trying to breach your hardpoint will be at a disadvantage. They won’t know where you’re positioned, and any attempts to enter will likely be heard, giving you the time and opportunity to respond.
Reduced Exposure to Ambush: By staying in a hardpoint, you avoid navigating dark or unfamiliar areas of your home, minimizing the risk of encountering an intruder who could have set up an ambush in another room.
Training and Preparation
Setting up a hardpoint is not a one-time preparation. Here are some ongoing steps to keep in mind:
Plan Regularly: Talk with your family about what to do if there’s an intruder. Identify the safest room in the house and make sure everyone knows to go there during an emergency.
Practice with Self-Defense Tools: If you have a firearm or other defensive tools, ensure you are trained in their proper and safe use. Regular practice will make you more prepared and confident if the need arises.
Run Drills: Practicing how to lock down in your hardpoint and call for help can be beneficial. Regular drills, much like fire drills, keep everyone aware and prepared for emergencies.
While the idea of clearing your home might seem appealing, statistics from military and law enforcement clearly show the dangers of this approach. The risks associated with room-clearing are high, even for those with years of specialized training. For most people, the safest course of action is to set up a hardpoint in your home, fortify yourself there, and call for help.
In a home invasion, creating a defensible position allows you to stay safe, gives you control, and minimizes the risk of a dangerous confrontation. By choosing to defend from a position of strength, you improve your chances of keeping yourself and your family safe without exposing yourself to the inherent dangers of room-clearing tactics.
More Online Violence Prevention and Self Defense Education
As a 501(c)3 nonprofit, our mission is to prevent violence by building skills and inspiring individuals to be agents of personal, community & cultural change.
The Center for Violence Prevention and Self Defense (CVPSD) offers a variety of public training programs designed to empower individuals with practical self-defense skills and violence prevention strategies. These classes are open to anyone looking to improve their personal safety, ranging from beginners to those with prior experience. The courses focus on a holistic approach to self-defense, covering essential topics like verbal de-escalation, situational awareness, and setting boundaries, alongside physical defense techniques. Participants are taught how to recognize and respond to potential threats while maintaining a calm and confident demeanor. Whether through workshops, seminars, or hands-on classes, CVPSD provides the tools and knowledge needed to navigate real-world scenarios safely and effectively. These public offerings ensure that people of all backgrounds have access to life-saving skills that can help prevent violence in their everyday lives.