Signal vs. Noise in Situational Awareness for Self-Defense
- william demuth
- Oct 29
- 6 min read
Updated: Oct 30
Situational awareness is noticing what is happening around you, understanding what it means for your safety, and choosing the next best action. It is not paranoia. It is paying smart attention so you can avoid problems early instead of wrestling with them late.
The simple version
See what is normal for this place and time. That is your baseline.
Spot meaningful changes to that baseline. Those are anomalies.
Decide what improves your position.
Do the small action now, not the big heroic one later.
What to look for
People. Who is here, what are they doing, who is watching whom.
Positions. Exits, barriers, corners, blind spots, vehicles.
Hands. Empty, occupied, hidden, fidgeting with a pocket or bag.
Movement. Closing distance, circling, blocking your path, re-approaching after you move.
Atmosphere. Sudden mood shifts, arguments turning physical, crowd compressing.
What do “signal” and “noise” mean?
Signal is information that helps you predict or prevent harm. Signals are meaningful changes from the normal environment that relate to safety, access, intention, or capability.
Noise is everything else. It is irrelevant, misleading, or emotionally exciting but not actionable. Noise eats attention and time.
In short, signal guides decisions, noise wastes them.
Baseline first, then anomaly
Situational awareness starts by noticing the baseline, which is what “normal” looks and sounds like for a setting and time of day. Once you know the baseline, you can spot anomalies. Most useful signals are anomalies that matter for safety.
Evening in a grocery parking lot: baseline is families loading bags, carts returning, engines idling briefly, people leaving.
Anomalies that might be signals: a person loitering between cars without bags, someone pacing and scanning faces, a vehicle following you through multiple rows.
Four quick filters for finding signal
Use these fast checks to separate signal from noise.
Relevance
Does this detail affect your safety or mobility right now, in this place?
If yes, it might be signal. If no, it is probably noise.
Pattern
Is it a one-off oddity or part of a pattern that is escalating?
Patterns carry more signal than single moments.
Proximity
Closer threats matter more. The nearer a person or vehicle is, the less time you have, which raises the importance of any cues.
Capability and access
Does the person have a way to reach you, and the means to cause harm? Access plus capability converts “interesting” into “actionable.”
Common signals in pre-attack behavior
These are red flags in many environments. None is proof of danger by itself, but together they build a strong signal.
Target glances: repeated quick looks at you, your hands, your pockets, or your exit.
Closing distance without purpose: especially on a diagonal line that leads your path.
Positioning for advantage: blocking your exit, herding toward a corner, approaching with a companion circling wide.
Hands hidden when they do not need to be: in pockets or inside a bag while approaching.
Unanswered boundaries: you say “Stop” or “I can’t help you,” and they keep coming.
Late-night loitering with scanning: watching arrivals rather than going about a task.
Sudden change in pace: a slow approach that becomes rapid once you commit to a door or car.
Common noise that traps attention
Rudeness or attitude: tone may be annoying but not dangerous. Focus on distance, positioning, and hands.
Clothing or appearance: style is rarely predictive. Behavior and positioning are what matter.
Background chaos: music, crowds, sirens, or other sensory clutter. Treat them as weather, not as decisions.
Your own storyline: “They look harmless” or “I am overreacting.” Stories can mute real signals.
Examples in different settings
1) Parking lot at night
Signal: a person steps from between cars when you pass, angles toward your path, one hand stays inside a hoodie pocket, they ignore your “Hey, give me space.”
Noise: loud music from another car, a shouting couple 60 yards away, a delivery van idling near the store.
Action: increase distance, change direction early, put the car between you and them, prepare verbal boundary and keys or light, move toward populated area. If they re-vector to follow your change, treat as a stronger signal.
2) Rideshare or taxi pickup
Signal: the driver insists you sit in front, locks doors immediately, deviates from the navigation route without explanation, mirrors your phone checks.
Noise: car model is older than the app photo, radio station you dislike.
Action: keep the door cracked until you confirm name and destination, set a friend share on location, ask for a reason for any route change, end the ride at a safe stop if needed.
3) Workplace reception
Signal: visitor refuses to sign in, tries to tailgate behind a badge holder, scans for cameras, asks where “back hall” is, plants feet near emergency exit.
Noise: irritated tone about wait times, loud phone call.
Action: hold firm on protocol, create distance, position yourself with a barrier, alert a teammate, escalate per policy.
4) Public transit platform
Signal: person watches the gaps behind commuters, aligns directly behind you as trains arrive, makes short test bumps, then repositions closer.
Noise: buskers, announcements, a tourist asking directions from ten feet away.
Action: step so your back is to a wall or pillar, keep space at the platform edge, change car position, make eye contact and a clear boundary if they shadow you.
Converting signal into decisions
Use a simple ladder: Notice, Decide, Do.
Notice
Name the anomaly in plain words. “He is closing distance with one hand hidden.”
Decide
Pick the smallest step that improves your safety. “Angle off to my right and use the parked SUV as a barrier.”
Do
Move your feet. If the person re-vectors to close again, escalate to the next step.
A practical escalation model: Eyes, Voice, Feet, Tools.
Eyes: see hands and path.
Voice: set a boundary, “Stop there.”
Feet: reposition, increase space, leave.
Tools: light, alarm, spray, or force if legally justified and necessary.
Quick scripts that reduce noise
Boundary: “Stop there. I cannot help you.”
Broken record: repeat the boundary one or two times, then move.
Public call-out: “You are too close. Back up,” which recruits social pressure.
Scripts let you act while adrenaline is spiking, and they keep you from negotiating with noise.
Drills to sharpen signal detection
Baseline walks
Spend two minutes at a new location, no phone, and list five baseline behaviors you see. Then list three anomalies. Do this in parking lots, lobbies, and transit stops.
10-5-2 scan
At 10 yards, look for path and obstacles. At 5 yards, check hands and hips. At 2 yards, it is protect and move, not analysis.
If-then cards
Write small rules and rehearse them. “If someone closes inside two arm lengths after I say stop, then I move behind a barrier and prepare my spray.”
Positioning game
With a partner, one person tries to take the other’s exit route using only footwork. The defender practices keeping an open lane to leave.
Phone discipline
Practice walking from door to car with the phone away, keys and light set, and a forced pause before unlocking. This trains attention back to signal.
Mistakes that turn signal into noise
Waiting for proof
You do not need certainty to act. You need a reasonable change that favors safety.
Fixating on a single cue
One odd movement is less meaningful than movement plus closing distance plus ignored boundary.
Letting politeness override safety
Courtesy is good. Safety comes first. You can apologize later if you misread.
Simple checklist
High-value signals
Closing distance without a clear reason
Ignored boundary or social cue
Hidden hands while approaching
Positioning that blocks your exit
Re-vectoring when you change direction
Team tactics, one engages while another flanks
Likely noise
Fashion or appearance
Tone without movement toward you
Background arguments far away
Your assumptions about “safe neighborhoods”
Distractions on your own phone
Bottom line
Situational awareness is not about being paranoid, it is about being precise. Establish the baseline, notice meaningful anomalies, and act early using small, practical steps. Treat behavior, distance, and access as signal. Treat everything else as noise. Then move your feet.
Online Violence Prevention and Defensive Tactics Training Brought To You By Generous Supporters
The Center for Violence Prevention and Self-Defense Training (CVPSD) is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to research and providing evidence-based training in violence prevention and self-defense.
Through a combination of online and in-person training, workshops, and seminars, CVPSD provides practical self-defense skills, violence prevention strategies, risk assessment tools, and guidance on setting personal and relationship boundaries.