top of page

Online Violence Prevention Conflict Resolution Training

The world's most extensive online violence prevention resource library, available for free.

Navigating Use of Force Scenarios: A Guide to Self-Defense

Updated: Oct 30, 2023

In the realm of self-defense, understanding the principles of navigating use of force scenarios is paramount to personal safety. When faced with a potential threat, individuals must make quick decisions about the level of force required to protect themselves while staying within legal and ethical boundaries. This article provides a comprehensive guide to help individuals navigate use of force scenarios effectively and responsibly.

Navigating Use of Force Scenarios: A Guide to Self-Defense
Navigating Use of Force Scenarios: A Guide to Self-Defense

I Would Rather Be Tried By 12 Than Carried By 6

The phrase "I would rather be tried by 12 than carried by 6" is often used to express a preference for facing a trial by jury rather than risking injury or death in a dangerous situation. While this sentiment may resonate with some, there are valid arguments against this perspective:

Legal and Ethical Responsibility: Society is built on principles of law and justice. Choosing to harm or kill another person without justification is a serious legal and ethical violation. Self-defense laws exist to protect individuals who are genuinely in imminent danger, but these laws also have limits to prevent misuse. Opting for violence instead of seeking alternative solutions can result in legal consequences and a lifetime of guilt.

De-Escalation and Conflict Resolution: Violence should never be the first option. There are often ways to de-escalate a situation, communicate effectively, and resolve conflicts peacefully. Embracing non-violent conflict resolution techniques can contribute to a safer and more harmonious society.

Moral and Emotional Consequences: Taking a life or causing severe harm can have profound moral and emotional consequences. Many individuals who have been forced to defend themselves using lethal force experience trauma and regret. Choosing violence should not be taken lightly, as it can have lasting psychological effects.

The Risk of Misjudgment: Assessing a threat accurately in high-stress situations can be challenging. What might initially seem like a life-threatening situation may not be. Rushing to violence without careful consideration can lead to tragic mistakes and irreversible consequences.

Legal Challenges: Even if one believes they are justified in using lethal force, the legal process can be lengthy, costly, and emotionally taxing. It is not a guaranteed escape from legal scrutiny or the possibility of conviction.

Promotion of a Violent Culture: The phrase itself perpetuates a culture that favors violence over peaceful resolution. Encouraging a mindset that prioritizes confrontation and force as the first response can contribute to a more aggressive society.

Alternative Measures for Self-Defense: There are numerous self-defense techniques and tools available that can help individuals protect themselves without resorting to lethal force. These include martial arts training, personal alarms, pepper spray, and non-lethal weapons, which can provide effective means of self-protection.

While the phrase "I would rather be tried by 12 than carried by 6" reflects a desire for personal safety, it should not be used as a blanket justification for choosing violence over other options.

Responsible self-defense involves considering all available means to protect oneself while adhering to the principles of legality, morality, and ethical conduct. Violence should always be a last resort, reserved for situations where there is no reasonable alternative to preserve one's life or the lives of others.

Understanding the Use of Force Continuum:

Use of force in self-defense is often depicted as a continuum that ranges from verbal commands and non-lethal tactics to lethal force. The appropriate level of force depends on the circumstances and the perceived threat. Key steps in navigating this continuum include:

  • Verbal Commands: Begin by attempting to verbally de-escalate the situation. Communicate calmly and assertively, setting boundaries and encouraging the potential threat to stand down.

  • Non-Lethal Force: If verbal commands prove ineffective, consider non-lethal options like pepper spray, personal alarms, or physical techniques designed to immobilize without causing severe harm.

  • Lethal Force: Lethal force, such as using a firearm, should only be considered as a last resort when there is an imminent threat to life or serious bodily harm. Laws governing the use of lethal force vary by jurisdiction, so understanding local regulations is crucial.

The Importance of Situational Awareness:

Situational awareness is the foundation of effective use of force decision-making. By staying vigilant and observant, individuals can better assess the threat level and make informed choices. Key aspects of situational awareness include:

  • Identifying Threat Cues: Recognize visual and behavioral cues that indicate a potential threat, such as aggressive body language, verbal threats, or brandishing weapons.

  • Assessing Surroundings: Be aware of your environment, noting escape routes, obstacles, and potential cover or concealment options.

  • Evaluating Multiple Threats: In scenarios involving multiple assailants, prioritize the most immediate threat and focus on de-escalation or defense strategies accordingly.

De-Escalation Techniques:

De-escalation is a critical skill in navigating use of force scenarios. It involves actions and communication designed to reduce tension and avoid physical confrontation. De-escalation techniques include:

  • Active Listening: Pay close attention to the potential threat's words and emotions, demonstrating empathy and understanding.

  • Maintaining Distance: Create space between yourself and the potential threat to reduce the likelihood of physical contact.

  • Remaining Calm: Keep emotions in check, as escalated emotions can lead to poor decision-making.

Legal and Ethical Considerations:

Understanding the legal and ethical aspects of self-defense is essential when navigating use of force scenarios. These considerations include:

  • Stand Your Ground vs. Duty to Retreat: Laws vary by jurisdiction, with some states having "stand your ground" laws that allow individuals to defend themselves without a duty to retreat. In other areas, individuals are required to retreat before using force if safe to do so.

  • Proportional Response: Use of force should be proportional to the threat. Employing excessive force may lead to legal consequences.

  • Avoiding Excessive Harm: Ensure that your actions do not cause unnecessary harm to the potential threat. The goal is to neutralize the threat, not cause undue suffering.

Navigating use of force scenarios in self-defense is a complex and challenging endeavor. It requires a combination of situational awareness, de-escalation skills, and a clear understanding of the legal and ethical boundaries surrounding self-defense.

By staying informed, prepared, and responsible, individuals can better protect themselves while minimizing harm to all parties involved. Remember, the ultimate aim of self-defense is to ensure personal safety while upholding the principles of justice and ethical conduct.

Violence Prevention and Self Defense Resources

The goal of the Center for Violence Prevention and Self Defense is to stop violence by educating at-risk people and empower them with the skills needed to protect themselves both online and live training. CVPSD's live training is available to people of all ages in New Jersey including children, adults and the elderly.

As a 501(c)3 nonprofit, our mission is to prevent violence by building skills and inspiring individuals to be agents of personal, community & cultural change.

Live conceptual seminars teach the origins of violence and how to assess risk and set boundaries for healthy relationships. Experiential classes teach hands-on interpersonal skills and strategies to prevent and stop assault. Our self defense instruction includes techniques from Jujutsu, MMA, krav maga, Kickboxing, and more.

The Center for Violence Prevention and Self Defense reaches individuals and communities through partnerships with schools and other nonprofits, community groups, as well as classes for the public. By reducing the fear and impact of violence, we help to create a community where people live powerfully, experience freedom.


bottom of page